What was new on START Web site?
August, 2001
August 26, 2001
The Russian-US consultations on strategic stability continued this week in Moscow. American delegation was lead by John R. Bolton, undersecretary of state for arms control and international security. On Wednesday, The New York Times run a sensational article claiming that Mr. Bolton said that the United States had given Russia an unofficial deadline of November to agree to changes in the Antiballistic Missile Treaty or face a unilateral American withdrawal from the arms control accord. The article referred to an interview, that Mr. Bolton had given to Echo Moscow news radio station. Later Mr. Bolton denied that he had issued any such deadline, either in his meetings with Russian officials or in an interview with a Moscow radio station. However, President Bush said on Thursday that the United States will withdraw from the 1972 Antiballistic Missile Treaty "at a time convenient to America."
- Russia Downplays ABM Remarks, (by Sharon LaFraniere, The Washington Post, Saturday, August 25, 2001; Page A14)
- November Is Almost Out Of Sight, - in Russian, (by Andrey Lebedev, Izvestia, August 25, 2001)
- What Are Stakes?, - in Russian, (by Georgi Bovt, Izvestia, August 25, 2001)
- Bush Is Going to Reject the ABM Treaty, - in Russian, (by Artur Blinov, Vremya MN, August 25, 2001)
- Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs Official Press Release, August 24, 2001
- Bush Flatly States U.S. Will Pull Out of Missile Treaty, (by David E. Sanger, The New York Times, August 24, 2001)
- ABM Withdrawal Likely, But Not Set, Bush Says, (by Amy Goldstein and Alan Sipress, The Washington Post, Friday, August 24, 2001; Page A01)
- George W. Bush: the U.S. Will Withdraw At Their Own Schedule, (Strana.Ru, August 24, 2001)
- Damn It All!, - in Russian, (by Stanislav Tarasov, Wek, August 24-31, 2001)
- Live up to November, - in Russian, (by Yuri Zhigalkin, Vremya MN, August 24, 2001)
- Cutting Down the Woods, - in Russian, (by Svetlana Babayeva, Georgi Bovt, Andrey Lebedev, Izvestia, August 23, 2001)
- U.S. Envoy Says Russia Has Time in Missile Talks, (by Michael Wines, The New York Times, August 23, 2001)
- U.S. Envoy Fails to Sway Russia on ABM Pact, (by Peter Baker, The Washington Post, Thursday, August 23, 2001; Page A20)
- U.S.: No Deal and We Scrap ABM Pact, (by Kim Gamel, The Moscow Times, Thursday, Aug. 23, 2001, Page 1)
- Bolton's Tricks Failed, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Vasilyev, Vremya MN, August 23, 2001)
- Transcript: U.S. Has Not Set a Deadline for Withdrawal from ABM Treaty, (Deputy Spokesman at Aug. 22 State Department daily briefing, 22 August 2001)
- Russian MFA Press Release on Russian-American Consultations on Strategic Stability, August 22, 2001.
- Moscow and Washington may not work out new strategic stability framework for the November Summit, - in Russian, (by Anton Bilzho, Viktor Sokolov, Strana.Ru, August 22, 2001)
- U.S. Sets Deadline for Settlement of ABM Argument, (by Patrick E. Tyler, The New York Times, August 22, 2001)
- Milk and Water, - in Russian, (by Yelena Shesternina, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 22, 2001)
- ABM Scenarios of the Future, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Vasilyev, Vremya MN, August 22, 2001)
- Transcript: Bolton Missile Defense Interview in Moscow , August 21, 2001
- U.S. Undersecretary Talks Defense, (by The Associated Press, The Moscow Times, Tuesday, Aug. 21, 2001. Page 3)
- US and Russian Undersecretaries "Agreed Not to Say a Word", - in Russian, (by Anton Bilzho, Strana.Ru, August 21, 2001)
- Consultations Will Continue, but Serious Results are Not Expected, - in Russian, (by Yuri Alekseev, Strana.Ru, August 16, 2001)
Media continue to discuss US Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld's visit to Moscow and his role in shaping American arms control policy:
- Keep Deterrence, (by Pavel Felgenhauer, The Moscow Times, Thursday, Aug. 23, 2001, Page 6)
- Rumsfeld's Doctrine, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Petrov, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 21, 2001)
- Donald Rumsfeld Doesn't Regard Russia even as an Enemy, - in Russian, (by Vladimir Dunayev, Izvestia, August 19, 2001)
- Moscow in 'Awkward Position' on Missile Defense, (by Charles Aldinger, Reuters, Thursday August 16, 8:09 PM ET)
- ABM Treaty Limits Our Capabilities, - in Russian, (by Sergei Sumbayev, Krasnaya Zvezda, August 15, 2001)
- Miscommunication in Moscow, The New York Times, August 15, 2001)
- Arsenals Key to Missile Dispute, (by Jon Boyle, The Moscow Times, Wednesday, Aug. 15, 2001. Page 3)
Debates on expediency of abandoning the ABM treaty continue in the US:
- Why Scrap the ABM Treaty?, (by Melvin R. Laird, The Washington Post, Thursday, August 23, 2001; Page A25)
- Face it, the cold war is over, (by Quentin Peel, Financial Times, August 20, 2001)
- Towards a Transatlantic Consensus on Missile Defense, (by Ivo Daalder and Christopher Makins, Survival, vol. 43, no. 3, Autumn 2001, pp. 61–66)
- Why Russians Fear Missile Defense, (by Alexander Altounian, The Washington Post, Wednesday, August 15, 2001; Page A19)
The Pentagon has given the green light for construction preparation work to begin on a U.S. missile-defense test site in Alaska in the next few weeks:
- Antimissile testing site approved, (by Charles Aldinger, Philadelphia Enquirer, August 22, 2001)
- Pentagon OKs Work on Missile Test Site, (by Reuters, Tuesday August 21 6:45 AM ET)
The next flight test of a prototype interceptor scheduled for October will essentially be a repeat of the July 14 exercise in which the system intercepted a mock warhead, rather than a more complex and difficult follow-up test because the military does not not yet have complete confidence in the "hit-to-kill" technology:
- Tougher Test Delayed for Missile Net, (by Esther Schrader, Los Angeles Times, August 16, 2001)
- 'Hit-To-Kill' Technology Not Sure Thing -Pentagon, (by Jim Wolf, Reuters, Wednesday August 15 2:45 PM ET)
Greenpeace activists that entered a restricted area at Vandenberg Air Force Base last month protesting a Star Wars missile defense test face criminal charges:
- 15 Face Felonies In Missile Protest, (by Jeff Adler and William Booth, The Washington Post, Sunday, August 19, 2001; Page A14)
- 11 Years in Prison for 40 Minutes Delay, - in Russian, (by Yevgeny Petrov, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 15, 2001)
Declassified archives revealed that 3450 kg Mark 15 hydrogen bomb was dropped 40 years ago from a B-47 Stratojet bomber after its aerial collision with an interceptor during a training flight and lies now 10 km off the US coast:
- Lost Atomic Lies on the Seabed off the US Coast, - in Russian, (Trud, August 16, 2001)
- Georgia can be Blown Up, - in Russian, (by Vladimir Tuchkov, Vesti.Ru, August 15, 2001)
A program conceived by the Clinton administration to rid the world of 100 tons of American and Russian weapons-grade plutonium is likely to be abandoned by the Bush administration:
- An Oven can't be Stoken up with Plutonium, - in Russian, (by Sergey Leskov, Georgi Bovt, Izvestia, August 23, 2001)
- Amercans Question the Expedience of Weapons-Grade Plutonium Utilization, - in Russian, (Lenta.Ru, August 21, 2001)
- U.S. Balks on Plan to Take Plutonium Out of Warheads, (by Matthew L. Wald, The New York Times, August 21, 2001)
At the Russian START Forum: on the Russian stance in the ABM dialogue, and other topics
August 15, 2001
Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld met President Vladimir V. Putin and Defense Minister Sergei B. Ivanov for consultations on strategic stability. Eugene Miasnikov, START Web site editor, comments the consultations in Izvestia: Consultations on Missile Defenses will not Go Forever, - in Russian, (by Svetlana Babayeva, Izvestia, August 14, 2001, p. 4). See also:
- Miscommunication in Moscow, The New York Times, August 15, 2001)
- Arsenals Key to Missile Dispute, (by Jon Boyle, Reuters, Wednesday, Aug. 15, 2001. Page 3)
- Why Russians Fear Missile Defense, (by Alexander Altounian, The Washington Post, Wednesday, August 15, 2001; Page A19)
- ABM Treaty Restricts Our Capabilities, - in Russian, (by Sergei Sumbayev, Krasnaya Zvezda, August 15, 2001)
- US fails to win Russia over on missile defence, (by Andrew Jack, Financial Times, August 14, 2001)
- Rumsfeld fails to sway Russia, (by Giles Whittel and Michael Evans, The Times, August 14, 2001)
- Russians Resolute on ABM Pact, (by Vernon Loeb, The Washington Post, Tuesday, August 14, 2001; Page A09)
- Moscow's Differences With U.S. Apparent During Talks, (by Thom Shanker, The New York Times, August 14, 2001)
- Putin Stands Firm on ABM Treaty, (by Robert Burns, The Moscow Times, Tuesday, August 14, 2001. Page 3)
- Wrong Ten Centimeters, - in Russian, (by Svetlana Babayeva, Georgi Bovt, Svetlana Popova, Izvestia, August 14, 2001)
- Consultations with US are Fruitless, - in Russian, (by Yelena Shesternina, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 14, 2001) - interview with Alexei Arbatov, Deputy Chair of the Defense Committee of the State Duma
- Anti-missile Ultimatum, - in Russian, (by Mikhail Khodarenok, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 14, 2001)
- Tomahawk will be Buried at a Ranch, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Antonov, Vremya Novostey, August 14, 2001)
- Intense Thinking, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Vasilyev, Vremya MN, August 14, 2001)
- Energetic Start of Successful Consultations, - in Russian, (by Ilya Bulavinov, Kommersant, August 14, 2001)
- Pentagon Verified Flight Time to Moscow, - in Russian, (by Stepan Osenchuk, Gazeta.Ru, August 13, 2001)
- Rose Gottemoeller: "US won't be in a Hurry to Withdraw from the ABM Treaty, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Bai, Izvestia, August 11, 2001)
- Rumsfeld Goes to Moscow, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Petrov, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 11, 2001)
Russian delegation led by Col. Gen. Yuri Baluyevsky, first deputy chief of Russia's general staff, visited Washington last week with the same purpose:
- The US doesn't Know How to Violate the ABM Treaty, - in Russian, (by Ilya Bulavinov, Kommersant, August 11, 2001)
- Missile Defense Outline became Clearer, - in Russian, (by Yuri Zhigalkin, Vremya MN, August 10, 2001)
- The Results of Consultations on Strategic Stability Between US and Russian Military Experts, - in Russian, (by Vladimir Abarinov, Svoboda, August 10, 2001)
- U.S., Russia Talk Missiles, (by Vernon Loeb, The Washington Post, Thursday, August 9, 2001; Page A13)
Gennady Khromov's recent comment Assessing Prospects of US-Russian Strategic Relations is now available in English.
Pentagon's acknowledgement of the fact that last month's successful test of a possible missile defense system was simplified (the interceptor missile used data from a homing beacon on the dummy warhead, also the kill vehicle's computers had been programmed with the shape and other physical characteristics of its target) stirred up a wave of criticism against hasty deployment of the system:
- ABM Slips, - in Russian, (by Vladimir Lyubetski, Krasnaya Zvezda, August 11, 2001)
- Pentagon Says Missile Killer Hit 'Sweet Spot', (by Vernon Loeb, The Washington Post, Friday, August 10, 2001; Page A05)
- On eve of Russia trip, US slates more missile-defense tests, (by Charles Aldinger, Boston Globe, August 10, 2001)
- Senate Leader to Challenge Bush on Missile Defense, (by Alison Mitchell, The New York Times, August 9, 2001)
- Democrats plan showdown on missile plan, (by Edward Alden, Financial Times, August 9, 2001)
Chinese leaders criticize US NMD deployment plans, while at the same time looking for an approach to the US in order to settle the problem:
- Jiang's Views, (by Erik Eckholm, The New York Times, August 10, 2001)
- Strategic Warmth, (by Thomas L. Friedman, The New York Times, August 10, 2001)
- Jiang Dodges Query on Missile Shield, (by Philip P. Pan, The Washington Post, Thursday, August 9, 2001; Page A14)
According to The Telegraph, UK Prime Minister Tony Blair has told President Bush that he supports American plans for a missile defence shield but cannot say so publicly for fear of further alienating Labour Left-wingers: Blair 'assures US of quiet support' on missile shield, (by Toby Harnden, The Telegraph, August 10, 2001)
Vladimir Khodakov, former executive officer of the USSR's General Machine-Building Ministry, recalls the history of development of the space-based component of the Soviet ABM system: Warheads on the Near-Earth Orbits?, - in Russian, (by Vitali Golovachev, Trud, August 14, 2001).
Greenpeace meetings protesting NMD deployment in conflict with both US and Russian authorities:
- Eleven Years In Jail For Forty Minutes Of Delay, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Petrov, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 15, 2001)
- 15 Antimissile Protesters Face Felony Charges, (The New York Times, August 12, 2001)
- Militia Against Those Who Against Missile Defenses, - in Russian, (by Svetlana Glinkina, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 10, 2001)
A program to upgrade aging Minuteman III intercontinental ballistic missiles has come under fire following tests showing the refurbished missiles are less accurate and have a shorter range than the ones they are replacing: Upgraded Missiles Found Less Accurate, (by Peter Pae, Los Angeles Times, August 9, 2001). See also: Missile maintainers finish treaty requirement early, (by Staff Sgt. Melissa Phillips, 90th Space Wing Public Affairs, Air Force News, August 13, 2001)
The US Navy's programme of conversion of ballistic missile nuclear submarines to cruise missile and special forces platforms received support from President George W. Bush: USN SSGN conversion gains support, funding, (by David C Isby, Jane's Defence Upgrades, 7 August 2001)
Experts continue to discuss the US administration's proposal to cut the B-1 forces: The Arithmetic of Bombing, (by William M. Arkin, Washingtonpost.com, Monday, August 13, 2001; 12:00 AM)
Russian strategic bombers Tu-160 (Blackjack) under a threat to be reduced to museum displays: Falcons Waiting for Kerosine, - in Russian, (by Nadezhda Andreyeva, Obschaya Gazeta, August 10, 2001)
August 8, 2001
Gennady Khromov, a member of Soviet delegation to START I talks, presented his comment Assessing Prospects of US-Russian Strategic Relations (in Russian) exclusively for our website.A high-level Russian team, headed by Colonel-General Yuri Baluyevsky, a top official from the main operations directorate of the Russian General Staff, was given a detailed insight into the Bush Administration’s proposals for a missile defence system for the first time yesterday:
- Russians at Pentagon for missile talks, (by Michael Evans, The Times, August 8, 2001)
- General's Assault on Missile Defense, (by Il'ya Bulavinov, Kommersant, August 8, 2001)
- In Penatagon and on "Avrora", - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Buy and Valeri Volkov, Izvestiya, August 8, 2001)
- U.S., Russia Meet at Pentagon, (by Barry Schweid, Associated Press, Tuesday, August 7, 2001; 11:16 AM)
White House National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice said that the Bush administration wants a "loose" framework with Russia that would replace the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty and permit the United States to build a national missile defense. According to an article published in a recent Time issue, "The rapid [NMD development] timetable is governed by political arithmetic: to lock in missile defense before Bush's first term ends. In fact, the President can just bulldoze ahead. Russia can cooperate and get something or sulk and get nothing. European objections don't count if Russia concedes. The Democrat-led Senate can't stop Bush from breaking the ABM treaty, though it can tighten the purse strings":
- At Gun Point of the American NMD, - in Russian, (by Yevgeni Grigor'yev, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 7, 2001)
- U.S. won't go solo on arms control, (by Lee Feinstein, The Baltimore Sun, August 6, 2001)
- Russian Tries to Pierce Missile Shield With Charm, (by Adam Clymer, The New York Times, August 4, 2001)
- Rice Aims for New Russia Framework, (by Barry Schweid, Associated Press, Friday, August 3, 2001; 2:57 AM)
- U.S. seeks flexible pact on ABM, (by Bill Gertz, The Washington Times, August 2, 2001)
- Russia and the US Start to Change the 1972 ABM Treaty, - in Russian, (by Igor Korotchenko, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, July 31, 2001)
- White House Says the U.S. Is Not a Loner, Just Choosy, (by Thom Shanker, The New York Times, July 31, 2001)
- A Salesman On The Road, (by Johanna Mcgeary, The Time, July 30, 2001, vol 158, no 4).
The North Korean leader, Kim Jong Il, repeated a promise to suspend ballistic missile launchings until 2003, saying in a declaration with President Vladimir V. Putin that his nation's missile program "does not present a threat to nations respecting North Korea's sovereignty." The declaration also said that "the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty is the cornerstone of strategic stability and the foundation of further reduction of strategic offensive arms":
- In the Interests of Global Stability, - in Russian, (Krasnaya Zvezda, August 7, 2001)
- Bush shield unites Putin and Kim, (by Ian Traynor, The Guardian, Monday August 6, 2001)
- North Korea to Help Russia to Com to an Agreement with the US , - in Russian, (by Gennady Sysoyev, Kommersant, August 6, 2001.
- Putin, Kim Sign Strategic Alliance, (by Paul Shin, The Moscow Times, Monday, Aug. 6, 2001. Page 1)
- North Korean Leader Vows to Curb Missile Program, (by Michael Wines, The New York Times, August 5, 2001)
- N. Korean Leader, in Moscow, Says Missile Plan Is No Threat, (by Peter Baker, The Washington Post, Sunday, August 5, 2001; Page A18)
While the Bush administration's missile defense plans have triggered opposition in Europe and Asia, at least half a dozen countries are cooperating with the Defense Department on research projects that could play an important role in America's anti-missile system: Allies Join Pentagon Research on Zapping Missiles, (by Vernon Loeb, The Washington Post, Saturday, August 4, 2001; Page A03)
Russian scientists "...make gross mistakes when assessing vulnerability of ballistic and space missiles to laser weapons by not taking into account low-threshold affect mechanism of the laser beam. Assessments published by some Russian academicians in public media seem to be overestimated at least by order of magnitude..." ("Star Wars" Turn into Reality, - in Russian, by Igor Korotchenko, Nezavisimoye Voeyennoe Obozreniye, August 3, 2001). See also:
- The Next Battlefield May Be in Outer Space, (by Jack Hitt, The New York Times, August 5, 2001)
- Air Force's Chief Backs Space Arms, (by Vernon Loeb, The Washington Post, Thursday, August 2, 2001; Page A17)
Since Bill Clinton left office, the Democratic Party has lost its focus on the contentious matter of national missile defense: Democrats' risk on missile defense, (by James Lindsay and Michael O'Hanlon, The Christian Science Monitor, August 2, 2001). See also:
- You Can't Get There From Here, (by Jon B. Wolfsthal, The Moscow Times, August 8, 2001)
- Missile Defense Clarity, (Carl Levin, The Washington Post, Wednesday, August 8, 2001; Page A18)
- The Myth of a Perfect Defense, (by Caleb Carr, The New York Times, August 7, 2001)
- Conservative Coalition Pushes Missile Shield on Capitol Hill, (by James Dao, The New York Times, August 6, 2001)
- Pentagon Predicts Clash Over ABM Is Coming in 2002, (by James Dao, The New York Times, August 1, 2001)
- Double Talk On Missile Defense, (by Michael O'Hanlon, The Washington Post, Tuesday, July 31, 2001; Page A23)
- 3 House Members Seek To Block Missile Site, (by Vernon Loeb, The Washington Post, Monday, July 30, 2001; Page A02)
Center for Nonproliferation Studies at the Monterey Institute of International Studies published an Occasional Paper Missile Proliferation and Defences: Problems and Prospects, (Center for Nonproliferation Studies, Occasional Papers: #7, July 2001)
The House Armed Services Committee authorized more than $8.1 billion for missile defense requested by the Bush administration for 2002. The approved bill includes $786 million for work on a new missile test bed in Alaska that could lead to deployment of missile interceptors there:
- Bush Wins House Panel Test on Missile Funds, (Reuters, August 2, 2001)
- The House Armed Services Committee Approved NMD Budget, - in Russian, (Strana.Ru, August 2, 2001)
- Americans to Spend $8 billion on NMD, - in Russian, (Utro.Ru, August 2, 2001)
At the same time, the committee voted to block the administration's plan to reduce the number of B-1 bombers from 93 to 60. The committee approved an amendment that prohibits any reductions or transfers of the bomber fleet until a series of reports and justifications are provided to Congress:
- House Panel Approves Limited Reduction of Arsenal, (by Walter Pincus, The Washington Post, Thursday, August 2, 2001; Page A20)
- Will US Reduce its Nuclear Arsenal?, - in Russian, (by Vladimir Lyubetsky, Nezavisimoye Voeyennoe Obozreniye, August 3, 2001)
- Much-Maligned B-1 Bomber Proves Hard to Kill, (by James Dao, The New York Times, August 1, 2001)
Russian Strategic Rocket Forces denied alleged secret test of a modified SS-25 missile reported by The Washington Times:
- Major Race, - in Russian, (by Dmitri Safronov, Izvestia, August 1, 2001)
- The Russians' rapid missile, (The Washington Times, July 31, 2001)
- Russian missile threatens US space shield, (by Giles Whittell, The Times, July 31, 2001)
- Moscow tests new missile, (by Bill Gertz, The Washington Times, July 30, 2001)
July 31, 2001: ten years since START-I was signed:
- The Only Treaty under Implementation, - in Russian, (by Dmitri Gornostayev, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 2, 2001)
- Statement by the Foreign Affairs Ministry of the Russian Federation On the Occasion of the Tenth Anniversary of the Signing of START Treaty
On current status of the Russian-American HEU-LEU program see: A Report on the Implementation by USEC Inc. of the Megatons to Megawatts Program (The 1993 Russian HEU Purchase Agreement), (Philip Sewell, Senior Vice President USEC Inc., presented at a Meeting of the Atlantic Council Washington, DC July 25, 2001)
"Nuclear bill" governing the import, reprocessing and storage of spent nuclear fuel from foreign nuclear power plants in Russia has been approved. However, that did not make it easier for the Minatom to implement the project: The Fight over the Market of Nuclear Waste Just Began, - in Russian, (by Yuri Chuvashev, Nezavisimaya Gazeta, August 2, 2001)
President Bush is proposing that a new military base-closing commission be empowered for the first time to recommend shutdowns of Energy Department nuclear weapons facilities: Bush plan to close bases eyes nuke sites, (by Rowan Scarborough, The Washington Times, August 6, 2001)
Thirty years ago there was a nuclear explosion near Galkino village. That was a secret nuclear explosion, a "peaceful" one: Ivanovo's Hiroshima, - in Russian, (by Yuri Vahrin, Rossiiskaya Gazeta, August 7, 2001)
At the Russian START Forum: on the alleged secret test of a modified SS-25 missile and other topics.
What Was New?
In 2001: January | February | March | April | May | June | July
In 2000: January | February | March | April | May | June | July | August | September | October | November | December
In 1999: January | February | March | April | May | June | July | August | September | October | November | December
In 1998: January | February | March | April | May | June | July-September | October | November | December
In 1997: November | December
Search the START Web Site
© Center for Arms Control, Energy and Environmental Studies at MIPT, 1999-2001